As you discern in your dilemma, the relinquishment of judgment is the discharge of the entire spectrum of judgment (the good throughout the negative). Total forgiveness (the Atonement) is actually a State of mind which demonstrates Summary Divine Intellect. Collecting a couple of passages from ACOL and presenting them facet https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCTleG6-484F7WHZD0hAjRRw